| Platinum | Cheesecakes Unlimited by Chey |
| Gold | Metro Diner |
| Silver | Bake For Eats |
| Bronze | Cone Slingers |
| Top Pick | A Taste of Everything |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | Country Boy's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Doumar's |
| Top Pick | Sugar Mama's Bakeshoppe LLC |
| Top Pick | Yummaries Bakery |