| Platinum | Metro Diner |
| Gold | Redwood Smoke Shack |
| Silver | Country Boy's BBQ |
| Bronze | Suffolk BBQ Co |
| Top Pick | Bubba N Frank's Smokehouse |
| Top Pick | Davis Boys BBQ |
| Top Pick | Davis Boyz BBQ |
| Top Pick | Pitt County BBQ |
| Top Pick | Q Daddy's Pitmaster BBQ |
| Top Pick | Texas Roadhouse |