| Platinum | Metro Diner |
| Gold | America's Best Wings Suffolk |
| Silver | America's Buffalo Wings |
| Silver | Country Boy's BBQ |
| Bronze | Baron's Pub |
| Top Pick | A Taste of Everything |
| Top Pick | Buffalo Wild Wings |
| Top Pick | Gourmet Burger Bistro |
| Top Pick | JW Barbecue & Wings |
| Top Pick | Sal's Pizza And Pasta |