| Platinum | Amicis |
| Gold | Al Forno Pizzeria |
| Silver | Ll Paesano Pizza |
| Bronze | Baron's Pub |
| Top Pick | Anna's Ristorante Italiano & Pizzeria Too |
| Top Pick | Atlas Pizza |
| Top Pick | Papa Johns Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sal's Pizza And Pasta |
| Top Pick | Spaghetti Eddie's Pizza Cafe' |
| Top Pick | The Box Gourmet Pizza |