| Platinum | Bubba's 33 |
| Gold | Baron's Pub |
| Silver | Kickback Jack's |
| Bronze | River Stone Chophouse |
| Top Pick | Brighter Day Cafe |
| Top Pick | Decent People |
| Top Pick | Derl'z Restaurant & Pub |
| Top Pick | Jack Brown's Beer and Burger Joint |
| Top Pick | Mason's Grill & Smokehouse |
| Top Pick | Nansemond Brewing Station |