| Platinum | Decoys Seafood |
| Gold | Surf Rider Restaurant |
| Silver | Sushi Aka |
| Bronze | Captain Chuck-A-Mucks Sandbar and Grill |
| Top Pick | 456 Fish |
| Top Pick | A.W. Shuck's |
| Top Pick | Amber Lantern Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Feather-N-Fin Chicken & Seafood |
| Top Pick | Norfolk Seafood Company & Big Easy Oyster Bar |